Bringing it all home

Sea-going oceanographers, like those aboard the R/V Sikuliaq today, have a cautionary principle that they always keep in the back of their minds.  When an expensive piece of scientific equipment, the vital infrastructure that makes up most of the budget for an ocean research team, goes over the side of a ship and into the sea you can’t expect for certain you will ever see it again.  The oceanographer designs every effort, makes every plan, and works every day to get the equipment and data back, but should never take as given that what goes in the sea will all return.

Dr. Jen MacKinnon and Dr. Matthew Alford wheel a mooring robot off the back deck.

Dr. Jen MacKinnon and Dr. Matthew Alford wheel a mooring robot off the back deck.

The ArcticMix mooring stands 3452 meters tall in the middle of the Beaufort Sea and when it was deployed early in September the scientists and crew of the R/V Sikuliaq literally watched as they let slip into the deep over half a million dollars worth of technology.  And while there are plans and backup plans for how we will again find this undersea treasure, everyone aboard will sleep better when each meter of wire and scientific baubles are again tied to the deck.  Still there is no better way to measure the ocean across its entire depth over a long period of time than employing ocean moorings.  These hard-won scientific data from the real ocean are essential to formulating and tuning the global climate computer simulations that inform decision-makers and regularly make the headlines.

The primary study zone for the ArcticMix voyage is right on top of what the National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC) has called ‘a striking feature of the late 2015 melt season’, a period that has ended as the fourth lowest Arctic sea-ice minimum on record.  Over 19 days, as the R/V Sikuliaq made additional ocean observations nearby, the ArticMix mooring stood steady listening and learning about its patch of the Beaufort Sea.

The Arctic is a strange place oceanographically, an up-side down version of the normal ocean in that the surface water is cold and fresh while lurking below is a reservoir of warmer, saltier water, heavier than the surface layer due to its high salt content.  One hypothesis in a rapidly-changing Arctic is that increasing open water allows storms to mix this deeper ocean heat upward through the generation of undersea beams of energy called ‘internal waves’, in turn melting more ice.  The peculiar nature of the Arctic is what makes a hypothesis of a positive climate change feedback based on vertical mixing possible.

Dr. Matthew Alford is ready to hook the float of the undersea mooring.

Dr. Matthew Alford is ready to hook the float of the undersea mooring.

In the first weeks of of our voyage the ArcticMix oceanographers witnessed remarkable levels of subsurface mixing.  Their sensitive instruments, leashed to the back of the R/V Sikuliaq by high-tech cables wrapped around specialized winches, saw billows of turbulence that looked just like a wave breaking on the beach, but much larger.  These underwater waves could easily reach into these regions of warmer water below the ice, possibly moving some of this heat upward when they break.

While the ArcticMix scientists darted across the Beaufort looking for signs of ocean mixing over wider swaths, the undersea mooring witnessed conditions minute by minute at a single location that serves as a scientific reference for the entire voyage.  The time comes to return to the scientific backbone of the entire experiment and find both the mooring equipment and all the invaluable data stored on many tiny memory cards, not unlike those in your nice camera except they are 3000 meters under the ocean.

Fair weather in the Arctic.

Fair weather in the Arctic.

The morning of the recovery breaks with fair winds and calm seas, the decks of the R/V Sikuliaq awash with sun for the first time since we had left Nome over 3 weeks earlier.  Best of all there was no ice to be seen.  Sea-ice, driven by the wind and currents, was completely out of our control and could easily have moved to cap the sea here, freezing our scientific assets beyond the reach of Sikuliaq.  The ArcticMix team won another calculated roll of the dice, as the risk of mooring a five hundred thousand dollar scientific bet in an ice-filled Arctic looked to be paying off.

A button is pushed and a special transducer puts a coded ping of sound into the water.  Somewhere, well over two miles below the stern of our ship, another device hears the command and releases its grip on the bottom.  The ArcticMix mooring rises slowly to the surface, four feet or so every second, and within 45 minutes it’s at the surface.  The top buoy is hooked and bit by bit and inch by inch the mooring is brought aboard in the Arctic sunshine.  Instruments are quickly washed and rushed back into the science lab for data transfer.  A team of graduate students and scientists swarm over the gigabytes of data filling the ships server and soon the first preliminary plots fill our computer screens.  The mooring has witnessed exactly the kind of wind generated internal waves we’ve been looking for.

Preliminary analysis of ocean currents measured by an undersea mooring over 19 days.

Preliminary analysis of ocean currents measured by an undersea mooring over 19 days.

One of the measurements captured on the undersea mooring is the velocity of currents through a wide range of ocean depths.  When these currents are displayed as a long series over time the clear signature of internal waves can be seen.  These beams of energy, generated by the storm that passed over the Beaufort Sea weeks earlier, descend into the deeper layers of the ocean where they can “break”, and as we observed elsewhere in the Arctic, heat can be mixed into surface waters a bit like hot coffee in cold cream.

What we have seen so far in the Arctic has certainly not refuted the hypothesis there there could be a positive feedback in regional changes in sea-ice cover that could lead to an increased rate of melting.  The marked energetic mixing we have seen here at the heart of the Arctic ice-melt zone could be a key in understanding a potential new climate feedback.  But for now the hard work lies ahead of the ArcticMix scientists for they must carefully untangle the complex processes involved to to distinguish typical seasonal melting from longer term change, with the goal of providing new insights that will help improve the accuracy of climate forecasts for the Arctic region.

  • Thomas Moore, for the ArcticMix team

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

When things go wrong

Making scientific observations at sea is by definition difficult and unpredictable and this is especially true north of the Arctic circle.

In a place like the Beaufort Sea, a marginal sea of the Arctic Ocean, the cold and extreme remoteness combine with the typical ocean challenges of corrosive salt-water, driving wind, and the stress and strain of violent motion to test equipment beyond the usual limits. A critical bit of machinery or electronics that would never ever fail back on dry land is basically guaranteed to do so somehow, somewhere on an oceanographic research cruise.

The broken sensor on the bench.

The broken sensor on the bench.

To guard against this a team like ArcticMix brings spare parts, lots and lots of spare parts, and tools and schematics and the kitchen sink. A high degree of redundancy to cover any and all contingencies is the rule and any exceptions can risk bringing data collection operations to a grinding halt. There always needs to be a backup plan.

With the planning, logistics, and operational effort for an oceanographic voyage often taking years, and every minute of time aboard being so costly, any equipment failures can become lost opportunities for science that every expedition works extremely hard to minimise. All the spares in the warehouse won’t save any scientific skin without a key catalyst – a team of experienced engineers, team “plan B”.

Wire runs all through the Sikuliaq. The ArcticMix team have run bundles wherever they fit, reaching out from the science lab and through the “Baltic room” – a sort of a hanger or garage for equipment that leads out onto the back deck. Just starboard of the centerline all the wires meet a special winch dedicated to the SWIMS towed system.

SWIMS, the “Shallow Water Integrated Mapping System”, hangs off it’s winch and is dragged through the upper layers of the ocean like a stone on a fishing line. In this case the line is a 1/3 inch six conductor electromechanical braided cable that carries power to the rig underwater, data back to the scientists on the ship in real time, and keeps the whole show from being snatched by the deep.

SWIMS needs to come home. Ethan Roth and Matthew Alford guide it in.

SWIMS needs to come home. Ethan Roth and Matthew Alford guide it in.

SWIMS provides a snapshot of ocean mixing across an ice-free Arctic at an unprecedented resolution, but to do so requires careful and dynamic winching of the towed-body relative to the sea surface. The winch drum needs to spool in and out hundreds of meters of cable neatly and cleanly without any tangles on a tossing, vibrating back deck subject to wind and driving freezing rain. At some point in the dark early hours something goes wrong with a small sensor on the SWIMS winch and the cable takes a skew wrap. The night watch has no choice but to stop operations and reach for the ships phone to wake the engineers from their restless sleep. ArcticMix needs a fix.

Frozen moisture is the arch-nemesis of electronic components and after a determined attempt to resuscitate the faulty part it becomes clear it’s beyond help. Unfortunately this tiny sensor is just one of a cascade of components on a custom winch where packing spares is impractical. There is no overnight shipping to the icy waters of the Beaufort Sea so the ArcticMix engineering team has to do something that is as remarkable as it is simply necessary – manufacture a new precision sensor from scratch with whatever parts and tools they can find aboard R/V Sikuliaq.

Mike Goldin with the new sensor they constructed aboard R/V Sikuliaq.

Mike Goldin with the new sensor constructed aboard R/V Sikuliaq.

A block of black delrin cut to specifications, a 500 Ohm potentiometer, a few globs of Scotchkote, and a whole lot of engineering design experience later and the ArcticMix team has a new sensor for the winch “level-wind”, the guiding hand that keeps the SWIMS cable from looking like the pair of headphones you just found in your backpack. The morning watch heads back out onto the fantail to launch the towed-body into the sea where it will profile the upper ocean layers across the Canada basin.

The Shallow Water Integrated Mapping System provides the ArcticMix scientists with an exclusive view of the the ocean physics in the Beaufort Sea. This oceanographic gadget, unique to the team from the University of Washington and Scripps Institution of Oceanography, will help answer questions about the character of mixing in the story of melting Arctic ice. But without the dedication and technical artistry of the sea-going engineers, skills that keep the wheels of science turning across a rolling sea, we’d be blind to the changes that are coming.

  • Thomas Moore, for the ArcticMix team

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

 

Media Release // Oceanographic team finds new clues to the ocean’s heat driving Arctic’s fourth lowest sea-ice minimum

Arctic Mix // Media Release

Oceanographic team finds new clues to the ocean’s heat driving Arctic’s fourth lowest sea-ice minimum

September 15th, 2015 – R/V Sikuliaq, Beaufort Sea

Today, as the National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC) announced the fourth lowest Arctic sea-ice minimum on record, an oceanographic team aboard the National Science Foundation’s R/V Sikuliaq is using unique instruments to explore the undersea secrets of ice-melt in the Beaufort Sea.  The ‘ArcticMix’ voyage leaders from UCSD’s Scripps Institution of Oceanography and University of Washington’s Applied Physics Lab are surprised by the strength of ocean mixing they have observed in their raw data.  Their findings, while preliminary, may change our understanding of the impact of climate change in the Arctic.

“The ArcticMix voyage is right on top of what the NSIDC has called ‘a striking feature of the late 2015 melt season’,” said Scripps Institution of Oceanography’s Dr. Jennifer MacKinnon, chief scientist aboard the R/V Sikuliaq.

“Our instruments are seeing billows of turbulence that look just like a wave breaking on the beach, but much larger.

“As a result, heat is being mixed up towards the surface, and the remaining ice, at a remarkable rate.

“While we hypothesised this might be happening, we have been genuinely thunderstruck by how incredibly strong the turbulence is below the surface.

“This heat is likely playing a substantial role in the melting of the ice that we can see all around us, growing thinner every day, and our job now is to distinguish summer melting from longer term change.

Dr. Matthew Alford, also from Scripps, explains the peculiar nature of the Arctic that makes this possible.

“One of the unusual things about the Arctic is that it’s an up-side down version of the normal ocean, in that the surface water is cold and fresh,” said Dr. Alford.

“Below that there is a lurking mass of warmer, saltier water, heavier than the surface layer due to its high salt content.

“One hypothesis for a rapidly-changing Arctic is increasing open water allows storms to mix this deeper ocean heat upward through the generation of undersea beams of energy called ‘internal waves’, in turn melting more ice.

“The marked energetic mixing we are seeing here at the heart of the Arctic ice-melt zone may prove key in understanding a potential new climate feedback,” Dr. Alford concluded.

Dr. John Mickett, from the University of Washington’s Applied Physics Lab where the unique oceanographic tools used to measure Arctic mixing were developed, describes the challenges of working in the Beaufort Sea.

“Our expedition is the first time these tools have been used in these waters and we have an outstanding opportunity to observe Arctic change,” said Dr. Mickett.

“Aside from the obvious science challenges of working in the Arctic, with extreme cold and adrift ice-chunks that are unfriendly to sensitive instruments, we are out here trying to sample and describe a moving target.

“The Arctic Ocean is changing quickly and past studies describing the dominant processes and general oceanography of the region may now be inaccurate or even obsolete,” Dr. Mickett concluded.

“It’s really incredibly exciting to be catching this Arctic ocean mixing in the act,” Dr. Mackinnon continued.

“The trick now will be to carefully untangle the complex processes involved, with the hope of providing new insights that will help improve the accuracy of climate forecasts for the Arctic region,” Dr. Mackinnon concluded.

The ArcticMix voyage aboard the R/V Sikuliaq is funded by the National Science Foundation and includes over 20 scientists, students, and technical staff from UCSD’s Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of Washington’s Applied Physics Lab, University of Alaska Fairbanks, MIT, Laboratoire de Physique, Lyon, and the University of Bergen.

ENDS

Arctic Mix Media Contact: 

Thomas Moore, aboard the R/V Sikuliaq > thomas.surman.moore@gmail.com

More information 

Blog: http://arcticmix.ucsd.edu

Images & Video: High-resolution images and video from Arctic operations are available on request.  Interviews: can be arranged with the scientists aboard R/V Sikuliaq via email or sat-phone

Anchoring an Arctic story down deep

Moore_31-08-2015_FUJIFILM_0574

Dealing with the 49″ Syntactic Foam Float on the back deck.

For most of us in our daily lives we think of our world in three dimensions.  We need to get up out of bed, across the floor, and through the door to the kitchen to make the coffee.  But when it comes to observing the physical nature of planet earth what is happening at a given location in three-dimensional space is only half of the story.

As part of their training one of the fundamental skills an oceanographer learns is to think beyond three dimensions, to include time and the change at a given location over time in their scientific perspective.  It’s not enough to go somewhere and have a look just once.  Without gathering data and building computer models in this fourth dimension we wouldn’t know that the sea-ice at the very spot in the ocean we are floating on at the moment has changed rapidly over the past twenty years.
So scientists talk about things they are observing in terms of space and time, scales of ocean measurement that fundamentally define how rich or spare their digital libraries of data become.  And how well sea-going oceanographers can see things over these scales are ultimately dependent on the scientific gadgets in their tool box and which ones they choose to put into water.
Mike Gregg , Matthew Alford, and Gunnar Voet at the wire.

Mike Gregg , Matthew Alford, and Gunnar Voet at the wire.

The research vessel Sikuliaq is a capable moving platform for our suite of custom ocean tools and her role is to take this technology all across the Beaufort Sea where it can best be put to use.  But a ship can’t be everywhere in the Arctic at the same time and so there are gaps, blind spots, but we can help fill those by deploying what ocean researchers call a mooring.
A mooring is a towering string of scientific instruments thousands of metres tall supported by giant floats at the top and held to the seabed by a beefy weight.  And on this mooring, this undersea science station, we put robots.
Crew of the R/V Sikuliaq ease a MP robot over the side.

Crew of the R/V Sikuliaq ease a MP robot over the side.

 Deploying an ocean mooring in over 3000 meters of water is no mean feat, it is one of the bread and butter professional competencies that a group like the ArcticMix team must have and work relentlessly to maintain.  A highly technical and often hazardous operation that can take many hours on the back deck of a ship like the Sikuliaq, mooring deployments are often exposed to whatever weather and waves the sea decides is right for the occasion.
This voyage the weather and seas were mostly kind and the ArcticMix mooring was happily fastened to the mud on the bottom of the Beaufort, its top float suspended in the ocean currents a bit like a giant balloon on a string swaying in a watery breeze.
Before the anchor is dropped the top floats of the ocean mooring trail behind the ship.

Before the anchor is dropped the top floats of the ocean mooring trail behind the ship.

Attached to this mooring are unique, recently developed ocean instruments called McLane profilers (MP’s).  MP’s are “wire-crawlers”, programable robots that descend and climb the mooring wire over and over and over again, one million metres worth of travel in their large internal lithium battery packs.
These profilers come jammed with an array of instruments that measure pressure, temperature, salinity, and most importantly current velocity across a longer vertical reach than any other tool in our oceanographic toolbox.  The following figure, calculated from MP data collected in the South China Sea in 2007, shows the kind of ocean current information that can be measured as time passes.  Scientists call it a “time series”.  
Mooring_robot_v01
While the ArcticMix team aboard Sikuliaq spends the coming month exploring elsewhere, our mooring, fixed in one location, can observe ocean parameters over a long period giving us a base of consistent information to anchor the wider story of Arctic change.
  • Thomas Moore, for the ArcticMix team

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Use this map to track the research vessel Sikuliaq

scripps oceanography uc san diego